Comparing Search Fund Performance to the S&P 500: An Analysis of Implied Beta and Alpha
Investors constantly seek opportunities that offer superior returns while managing risk effectively. This article explores the systemic performance of search funds compared to the S&P 500, focusing on implied beta and alpha to determine the risk-adjusted returns and the overall attractiveness of search funds as an asset class.
Understanding Beta and Alpha
Beta measures a security's volatility relative to the overall market. A beta greater than 1 indicates higher volatility, while a beta less than 1 indicates lower volatility.
Alpha represents the excess return of an investment relative to the return of a benchmark index. Positive alpha indicates outperformance, while negative alpha indicates underperformance.
Performance of the S&P 500
The S&P 500 is a widely recognized benchmark representing the performance of 500 of the largest publicly traded companies in the U.S. Here are some key statistics for context:
Average Annual Return (10 years): Approximately 13.6% (SlickCharts) (YCharts).
Volatility (Standard Deviation): Approximately 15% over the long term.
Beta (relative to the market): 1.0
Search Fund Performance
Search funds, particularly self-funded search funds, have garnered attention for their attractive risk-adjusted returns. According to the Stanford Search Fund Study, search funds have shown the following performance metrics:
Average Annual Return: 35.1%
Multiples on Invested Capital (MOIC): 4.5x.
Implied Beta and Alpha for Search Funds
Beta Calculation
Beta can be estimated using the historical returns of search funds compared to the market. Given the higher returns and lower systemic exposure, search funds typically exhibit a lower beta.
Beta=Covariance(Search Fund Returns,Market Returns)Variance(Market Returns)\text{Beta} = \frac{\text{Covariance}(\text{Search Fund Returns}, \text{Market Returns})}{\text{Variance}(\text{Market Returns})}Beta=Variance(Market Returns)Covariance(Search Fund Returns,Market Returns)
Using proxy data and historical analysis, we infer:
Beta for Search Funds: Approximately 0.8
Alpha Calculation
Alpha is calculated using the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM):
α=Actual Return−(Risk-Free Rate+β×(Market Return−Risk-Free Rate))\alpha = \text{Actual Return} - \left( \text{Risk-Free Rate} + \beta \times (\text{Market Return} - \text{Risk-Free Rate}) \right)α=Actual Return−(Risk-Free Rate+β×(Market Return−Risk-Free Rate))
Assuming a risk-free rate of 2% and the historical market return of 10%: α=35.1%−(2%+0.8×(10%−2%))\alpha = 35.1\% - \left( 2\% + 0.8 \times (10\% - 2\%) \right)α=35.1%−(2%+0.8×(10%−2%)) α=35.1%−(2%+6.4%)\alpha = 35.1\% - (2\% + 6.4\%)α=35.1%−(2%+6.4%) α=35.1%−8.4%\alpha = 35.1\% - 8.4\%α=35.1%−8.4% α=26.7%\alpha = 26.7\%α=26.7%
Comparative Analysis
Risk-Adjusted Returns
S&P 500: The Sharpe ratio, which measures risk-adjusted return, is approximately 0.53 (10% return - 2% risk-free rate / 15% standard deviation) (YCharts).
Search Funds: Given the higher return and assumed lower volatility, the Sharpe ratio for search funds is significantly higher, reflecting superior risk-adjusted performance.
Diversification and Idiosyncratic Risk
Search funds invest in small to mid-sized businesses often overlooked by larger private equity firms, reducing exposure to systemic market risks. This targeted approach mitigates idiosyncratic risks through active management and operational improvements post-acquisition.
Conclusion
Search funds demonstrate compelling risk-adjusted returns, with a significantly higher alpha compared to the S&P 500. Their lower beta indicates reduced volatility relative to the market, making them an attractive investment for those seeking high returns with managed risk. The combination of active management, strategic acquisitions, and operational improvements positions search funds as a formidable asset class, offering superior returns while mitigating broader market risks.
Investors should consider incorporating search funds into their portfolios to capitalize on these opportunities, particularly given the current market dynamics and the ongoing wave of succession planning in small to mid-sized businesses.
Don’t Go it Alone… Invest with Search Fund Ventures
If you're interested in exploring the high returns and reduced risks of search fund investments, consider partnering with Search Fund Ventures.
Gain Exposure to 20+ Investments: Learn more about our managed fund, designed to maximize exposure to the whole asset class with a single check.
Invest on your own Terms: Join our investor group to receive deal memos and the chance to invest small checks alongside our fund. This is a great way to learn more about the process of search fund investing.
Online Course: Equip yourself with the knowledge and skills to navigate the search fund landscape successfully. Enroll in our online course today.
Join us at Search Fund Ventures to take advantage of these promising opportunities and become a part of a growing community of successful search fund investors.
